How to Make Money with Amazon Online Arbitrage [2024]

Online arbitrage can be extremely profitable for ecommerce businesses - especially when you take into account that 43% of U.S. consumers prefer shopping online. And given the ease that suppliers now have with sourcing products and materials, it can be easier than you’d think to launch and sustain an online arbitrage business, even on a massive marketplace like Amazon.

However, to be successful with arbitrage, you’ll need to put in the work. Amazon alone counts over 2.5 million products listed on its platform, which means competition is fierce. To sell on Amazon and make a profit, entrepreneurs have to consider everything about their potential online arbitrage: from the products they choose to how they’ll market themselves as reputable sellers.

Here’s a guide on how to push your ecommerce arbitrage business to profitability.

Psst... if you're looking for more info about retail arbitrage on Amazon, check out our Complete Guide to Retail Arbitrage here.

What is Online Arbitrage?

Online arbitrage is a business model that works by buying products (usually wholesale) from one market and selling them for a higher price in another market. The difference in price in these two markets is what makes businesses their profits.

Marketplaces such as Amazon can help even the smallest sellers get profits by selling products on their platform. Considering that the Amazon marketplace sees billions in visits and millions in purchases, business models like online arbitrage can help sellers reach these audiences.

Amazon is by far the most popular platform for online arbitrage, but it’s not the only place where you can sell products. Any other online ecommerce platform is a viable place for online arbitrage, as long the platform allows it and you follow its rules and regulations. The flexibility of this business model—and the potential demand—can make it a very successful career for any aspiring online entrepreneur.

Is Online Arbitrage Legal?

While the concept of “flipping” has admittedly carried some negative connotations (mostly in the housing market), ecommerce arbitrage is perfectly legal. It’s encouraged by online marketplaces for the following reasons:

• Helps distribute products across different markets, avoiding product monopolies
• Gives consumers new channels to access goods that they may not have had before
• Encourages competition between businesses, keeping the markets dynamic and innovative
• The movement of products across borders and platforms contributes to product development
• Allows prices to stabilize long-term depending on market demand

While there are specific regulations regarding arbitrage—such as some brands and online retailers not allowing their products to be resold—ecommerce platforms and regulations allow online arbitrage. Combined with the overall demand for products globally, there’s a considerable possibility of turning a profit.

Why Choose Online Arbitrage?

Online arbitrage isn’t the only way that sellers can generate profit: dropshipping and white-label businesses also do well on marketplaces, especially on Amazon and Walmart. Most marketplaces have little to no restrictions about the type of business sellers can run, if their regulations are followed.

Like anything, this business type has its pros and cons, but there are some key benefits to online arbitrage that make it ideal for anyone looking to profit: 

Low Barrier of Entry for Arbitrage Beginners

Anyone can make an Amazon Seller account, but what makes online arbitrage easier for beginners is that they’re not locked into a specific scale of operations or stock to get started with online arbitrage. You can start with as little or as much product as your bottom line will allow, with the flexibility to transition to different products as you want.

Keeping in mind fees and other upkeep costs (which will be discussed later), online arbitrage doesn’t require as much upfront costs compared to other business models. A small team can operate an online arbitrage business, with the possibility of getting significant returns on investment.

Easy Sourcing of Products

You can reasonably run an arbitrage business from the comfort of your home, with a reliable internet connection. Because you can avoid the time-consuming product development process, you can focus on finding the best deals and profit margins for the products you want to sell. And all of that sourcing can be done online.

Retail and wholesale also allow for this approach: many sellers will often source their products through online channels. More involved businesses may choose to physically inspect the site and goods being manufactured, but many online arbitrage sellers can operate almost entirely online.

Somewhat Predictable Product Demand

Because you’re reselling products from one market to another, you only need to make sure that the product that you’re trying to sell can generate profit. This is generally easier to do with branded products (since consumers will often make their demand visible online or via researching trends) than launching a product by yourself or relabeling a white-label brand.

With predictable demand, you can scale your online arbitrage up or down as your market responds to your sales. This lowers overall risk and can help support your bottom line even if some of your product lines don’t perform as well as others.

Quick Startup

Given all the above, it’s surprisingly easy to start an online arbitrage business, especially on ecommerce platforms like Amazon, which has streamlined the startup process. Usual regulations like quality assurance, trademark registration, or product development—all of which can slow down the launch of your product or brand—aren’t a concern for online arbitrage.

Additionally, there are tools and software that you can use to drastically shorten or even automate the steps that you need to go through to launch your online arbitrage business. While these tools are not required to start and operate an online arbitrage business, using them can lead to significant savings in time and resources long-term. For example, would you rather spend your weekend driving around to dozens of retail stores to source products - or get it done in two hours from your couch instead? 

Making Profits From Online Arbitrage

So far, we’ve shown how (and why) online arbitrage can be a profitable venture. But as we’ve also mentioned earlier, it’s a competitive market—and if you want to make a profit, you’ll need to take steps short and long-term to ensure that you’re getting a significant return on investment.

Here are some of the approaches you can use to make your online arbitrage profitable.

Invest Time into Product Research

Your products are at the core of what makes your business successful: so much of your time should be devoted to product research. While it can be easy to ascertain demand based on strategies like research and social listening, it’s also important to dive into the driving forces that make people want to buy a product.

While the specific guidelines can differ based on what products you want to focus on, there are general guidelines you can follow to judge whether a product will get you the profit you’re looking for:

• Availability. Your specific product should have very little or no channels that your targeted audience has access to. While this can be difficult based on what and where you’re selling, it’s a baseline that you should always start from to ensure maximum profit.
• Seasonal demand. Seasonal goods can still be sold via online arbitrage, but their fluctuating demand makes them a less reliable source of profit long-term. Additionally, the costs associated with sourcing these products can drastically differ depending on whether they’re in or out of season, which can tank your bottom line.
• Product niches. Unless you’re sure about product demand, it’s best to avoid small niches when looking for products to sell. These niches will often require special considerations when it comes to product manufacturing or packaging, which will often be too costly for any seller smaller than a large enterprise.
• Regulatory guidelines. Brands are generally fine with being resold by online arbitrage sellers, but there may be an odd exception that you may not be aware of until you check. Likewise, make sure that your selected ecommerce platform allows the sales of your chosen product under its own guidelines.
• Product quality. Above all else, make sure that the product you’re looking to sell is good quality. Marketplaces are generally very unforgiving to new products with shoddy quality. So while you may make some sales during the initial buy-ins, you’ll quickly lose both profit and customers long-term.

By investing time into product research, you’ll be able to start your product launch without any worry about the product itself. This ensures that you can focus on marketing, fulfillment, and finding more products to sell.

Account for Fees

One thing that most sellers tend to forget is how much fees can add up, especially if a business settles in for long-term operations. While online arbitrage can have low entry costs, these calculations may not always account for the fees needed for upkeep long-term.

Some ways to manage this issue include:

• Smart accounting. Many marketplace management tools include calculators that can give you a detailed breakdown of how much it may potentially cost to add a product to your storefront. Making use of these tools before launch or investment in any product can help you get a clear idea of how feasible it will be to sell the product you’re looking to launch.
• Negotiate with suppliers. Most fees will typically come from the ecommerce platform that you’ll be using to sell your products, and they’ll often be non-negotiable. However, this gives you the freedom to negotiate with your source for the pricing of your product to help offset these costs. Don’t be afraid to negotiate prices, including shipping costs, especially if you have the data to back up that your product will sell well
• Check with regulations. ecommerce platforms can sometimes change their terms about how much their fees may cost, which can drastically affect your total expenses for your storefront. Keeping track of these changes when they occur can help you plan and mitigate any potential additions to costs for your products.

Remember: sales and profit are two completely different things for any seller. Fees should always be accounted for directly after sales for a more accurate profit forecast. Calculating fees can help with the growth of your business while also helping you stay compliant with the regulations of your chosen ecommerce platform.

Reliable Fulfillment and Product Sourcing

Fulfillment and sourcing are other crucial issues that most online arbitrage sellers have trouble with. While it doesn’t directly affect profit, the issues that come with not having these two areas optimized can slow down sales and indirectly cause a loss of profit.

To avoid this, online arbitrage sellers can:

• Partner with Amazon’s distribution network. Many sellers don’t have the infrastructure or inventory space to keep the products that they buy, which Amazon can help with. While these may add to the upfront fees, they can help lessen the load of fulfillment and shipping for sellers. It also increases your chances of landing on Amazon’s Buy Box, which can drastically help with product exposure.
• Source from multiple providers. Ideally, businesses can choose one specific provider to source their products for fewer moving parts in the product research and launch process. However, it’s also a good idea to have multiple sources of the same product (even just as a reference) to account for sudden surges or changes in demand.
• Avoid retailers. This isn’t always possible, but online arbitrage sellers should always buy wholesale or straight from the manufacturer, rather than any retailers. This is because retailers often sell at a higher price compared to buying products straight from the source, which limits how much profit you’ll make from your sales. It’s fine to keep some retailers in your network to source goods in a pinch, but most of your product should come from bulk purchases.

Optimizing product sourcing and fulfillment can admittedly add to your costs when launching a new product or setting up your storefront, but the avoided penalties and other potential costs down the line can more than make up for it. A consistent product inflow means you’ll be better stocked to meet consumer demands, which ultimately leads to steadier profits.

Focus on Personalization and Customer Service

Online arbitrage sellers face a somewhat unique challenge: how to make themselves the preferred option for customers. Consumers today have access to plenty of marketplaces and even more price points, so you need to work toward not just making your products affordable but also pushing yourself as a trusted and preferential seller.

The most reliable way to do this (aside from pricing) is to work on your customer service. Some approaches include:

• Optimize your storefront. Customers don’t want to spend too long searching for the things they want to buy—and on large platforms like Amazon, attention is limited and valuable. Doing things like optimizing your listings can go a long way to helping your products land on the radar of your consumers.
• Invest in marketing. Marketing is how you’ll be able to distinguish yourself as a seller. Running promotions or special campaigns will help you present yourself as a reliable source of the products that your customers want.
• Respond to customer queries. Feedback is crucial for any storefront. Online arbitrage sellers should have a dedicated support team or a process that can manage customer concerns and refunds. Not only will this improve their overall experience, but it can build trust in you as a seller in general.

While there isn’t a lot of wiggle room for brands to personalize the products that they sell as an online arbitrage business, committing to a high standard can help set them apart from their competitors. Personalizing service can often have a comparable effect on pricing if done right. And in many cases, it may be the deciding factor that makes your products profitable.

Tools you can use to supercharge your Amazon arbitrage business

Online arbitrage is a complex operation that requires comprehensive oversight of various aspects of your business. These tools not only give you the visualization necessary to make sense of all your data, but they also give you actionable approaches to improving your business.

Amazon FBA Revenue Calculator

For new sellers, the Amazon seller app provides useful tools to get started. The platform offers a Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) Revenue Calculator to give sellers a clear idea of the costs and profit potential for their products when selling on Amazon.

However, Amazon’s FBA calculator is limited in the insights and data it can give you, particularly for online arbitrage sellers. While it works well for most Amazon merchants, online arbitrage sellers may find it lacking crucial features that help their business model function, like automating searches for profitable products.

Threecolts

Threecolts is a comprehensive marketplace management platform with a variety of features that can help an online arbitrage business run efficiently. With Threecolts, Amazon sellers can enjoy actionable insights, long-term growth, and increased engagement with customers. Two particularly useful tools that can help with online arbitrage are TacticalArbitrage and SellerRunning.

Tactical Arbitrage allows Amazon sellers to search for products without manual input, source the best-selling products, and analyze the performance of their competitors who carry the same product. This tool allows you to get started with your online arbitrage quickly, which is crucial when launching new and in-demand products.

On the other hand, SellerRunning helps you update your listings without having to go through every single entry. With its Google Chrome extension, it drastically simplifies product research by adding the most profitable products in a single click. It also allows sellers to keep track of the fulfillment status of all their orders for better customer service—a key metric to getting ahead as an online arbitrage business.

AMZScout

AMZScout’s Amazon Product Database uses premade product categories to help sellers find the most profitable products on the market, but it can also be filtered for more extensive searches. This helps sellers find products that are not only profitable but can also compete with the product lines of their closest competitors.

Alternatively, sellers that already have specific products in mind can use AMZScout Amazon Dropshipping, Arbitrage, and Wholesale Extension for an in-depth look at specific products, their price points, how popular they are, and the potential profits that can be made from them. 

Become a Successful Online Arbitrage Seller with Marketplace Management Software

As an online arbitrage seller, you can take advantage of new markets, bringing new products to new customers and increasing their likelihood of profit. Get access to quality tools and software that can make managing your business much easier, and you have an entrepreneur’s essential foundation for making a profitable business. Try the Threecolts platform to get started with your online arbitrage today.

Browse through and read our other blog posts that are data-driven insights with our very own proprietary data and learn more on Mother's Day trends and best practices, Easter sales, price elasticity of demand, Amazon FBA fee changes, Amazon product title optimization, winter seasonal products, Amazon end of year sales, Valentine’s Day trends and best Amazon fulfillment centers by location and throughput.